Nashville's Painters — Middle Tennessee (615) 455-2733 Free Estimate
Home Interior Painting Exterior Painting Cabinet Refinishing Drywall & Texture Repair Deck & Fence Staining Commercial & Rentals Service Area Second Coat About Get a Free Estimate

Painting · Nashville, TN

Storing Leftover Paint Through a Nashville Winter

The half-empty cans on the garage shelf are your touch-up paint, if they survive the winter. Where to keep them, how to close them, how long they last, and what Davidson County does with the ones you no longer want.

We respond immediately Licensed and insured local crews Free, no-obligation estimates

· by Michael Blair, Nashville's Painters

Every paint job we finish leaves something behind: a partial gallon of the wall color, a quart of trim, the ceiling white. Those cans are the only paint that will match the walls when a picture hook comes out or a chair scuffs the hallway, and most of them spend the winter on a garage shelf. Here is where the paint makers say leftover paint should live instead, how to close a can so it keeps, how to tell when it has gone bad, and what Metro asks you to do with paint you no longer want, whether it came from an interior paint job or the outside of the house.

Is a garage a good place to keep paint over the winter?

A garage is a poor place to keep paint over the winter, and the paint makers say so. Sherwin-Williams’ guide to storing and disposing of leftover paint ranks the garage among the worst spots in the house because its temperature swings: paint there tends to freeze in cold weather and get too hot in summer. Both it and Benjamin Moore’s tips for storing leftover paint give 60 to 80 degrees Fahrenheit as the range to keep it in, and Benjamin Moore tells anyone keeping paint in a garage to make sure it does not freeze.

Middle Tennessee gets enough hard freezes to make that a real risk, which is also why our post on the last month to paint outside ends the exterior season when it does. Sherwin-Williams suggests a closet, utility room or basement instead, and in a basement it wants the cans up on a shelf, since damp floors can rust them. In most Nashville houses a hall or utility closet is the easiest of those to give up a shelf in.

How do you store leftover paint so it works for touch-ups?

Leftover paint stays usable for touch-ups when the can is airtight and you know how old it is. Sherwin-Williams’ method is to wipe the rim clean, lay plastic wrap over the opening, set the lid on top and tap it closed with a rubber mallet, then write the month and year the can was opened on the lid. Benjamin Moore adds that if the paint goes into a different container, it should not be much bigger than what is left, so there is little air inside.

We would add the room and the surface to the date, so the trim paint is not mistaken for the hallway walls three years from now. Even well-kept paint does not always blend in when it goes on as a patch, and our post on why touch-up paint never quite matches the wall explains when repainting the whole wall is the better answer.

How long does leftover paint last once opened?

Leftover paint lasts about two years once opened, for most products. Benjamin Moore gives that figure for most of its paints and others’, and Sherwin-Williams calls two years a good rule of thumb for latex, while saying oil-based paint stored well can last up to 15 years. Benjamin Moore notes that the storage conditions, temperature swings among them, affect that figure.

The can will usually tell you when it has spoiled. Sherwin-Williams points to a rancid smell in latex, a hard skin across the top and liquid that separates and will not stir back in. Benjamin Moore describes a sour, strong smell and paint that stays lumpy or jelly-like after stirring, when it should be smooth. Neither maker’s page says what one freeze does to a can, so we judge a can that has spent a cold night in the garage the same way: open it, smell it, stir it, and if it fails any of those, it is done.

How do you get rid of old paint in Nashville?

Getting rid of old paint in Nashville depends on what kind it is, and the label settles that. Metro’s latex paint disposal sheet says latex cans read latex, water-based or acrylic, while oil-based cans say oil based or alkyd.

Latex is not treated as hazardous waste, so Metro asks you to dry it out rather than bring it in: leave the lid off a can with an inch or less in the bottom until it hardens, out of reach of children and pets, or stir shredded paper, sawdust, kitty litter or a paint hardener into a fuller can. A dried can goes into the household trash in a bag. The sheet adds that paint never goes down a storm drain, sink or toilet.

Oil-based paint goes the other way. The current household hazardous waste page for Nashville and Davidson County lists oil-based paint, stain and paint thinner among what the East and Ezell Pike convenience centers will take for free, and puts latex and acrylic paint and water-based stain on the list they refuse.

The EPA’s household hazardous waste page counts paint among household products that can contain hazardous ingredients, and pouring them down a drain or onto the ground among the wrong ways to be rid of them. The latex sheet dates from 2014, so call Metro Waste Services at 615-862-5000, the number its current page gives, before a trip. For walls that need painting rather than touching up, ask us for an estimate.

Sources

FAQ

Storing Leftover Paint Through a Nashville Winter — questions

Can you store paint in the garage?

It is one of the worst places for it, according to Sherwin-Williams, because paint in a garage tends to freeze in winter and overheat in summer. Sherwin-Williams and Benjamin Moore both say to keep paint between 60 and 80°F, so a closet, utility room or a basement shelf is better.

How long is leftover paint good for?

About two years once the can is opened, for most paints, according to Benjamin Moore; Sherwin-Williams gives the same rule of thumb for latex and says well-stored oil-based paint can last up to 15 years. Writing the month and year on the lid when you open it tells you where you stand.

How can you tell if old paint has gone bad?

Smell it and stir it. Sherwin-Williams lists a rancid smell, a hardened skin on top and liquid that separates and will not mix back in. Benjamin Moore describes a sour, strong smell and lumps or a jelly-like texture that remain after stirring. Paint that fails those checks should not go on a wall.

How do I get rid of latex paint in Nashville?

Dry it out and put it in the trash. Metro’s disposal sheet says to leave the lid off a can with an inch or less of paint, or stir shredded paper, sawdust, kitty litter or a hardener into a fuller can, then bag the dried can for regular trash. Metro’s drop-off centers do not accept latex paint.

Where can I take oil-based paint in Nashville?

Metro’s household hazardous waste page lists oil-based paint among the items accepted free at the East and Ezell Pike convenience centers. Check the label for the words oil based or alkyd. Call Metro Waste Services at 615-862-5000 before you go, since accepted items and rules can change.

Free estimate

Time for fresh paint?

Show Nashville's Painters the rooms or the siding, and our written estimate, free and with no obligation, lists the prep, the coats and the paint.

Call Chat Free Estimate
Thinking about fresh paint?